A1
Classifiers, and the one Mandarin cannot copy
How Cantonese classifiers work, the common ones, and the bare-classifier construction that marks a noun as definite — something Mandarin has no way to do.
A number cannot touch a noun. Something goes between them, as in Mandarin.
一個人
jat1 go3 jan4
one person
三本書
saam1 bun2 syu1
three books
兩杯咖啡
loeng5 bui1 gaa3fe1
two cups of coffee
個 is the general-purpose one, as in Mandarin. The rest overlap heavily with the Mandarin set and diverge in a few useful places: 架 for vehicles and machines where Mandarin uses 辆 or 台, 間 for rooms, shops and buildings, and 隻 far more widely than Mandarin 只 — animals, one of a pair, and also plates, cups and boats.
The ones to learn first
| 個 | the general one, and people |
| 本 | books |
| 張 | flat things — paper, tables, beds |
| 隻 | animals, and one of a pair |
| 杯 | cupfuls |
| 件 | clothes, and abstract matters |
| 條 | long things — roads, fish, trousers |
| 架 | vehicles and machines |
| 間 | rooms, shops, buildings |
個 is the fallback when the right one escapes you, and it is far more tolerated in Cantonese than 个 is in Mandarin. 件 is worth noting for its second use: 一件事, a matter, where nothing physical is being counted.
三件衫
Saam1 gin6 saam1.
three items of clothing
一條魚
Jat1 tiu4 jyu4.
one fish
兩張枱
Loeng5 zoeng1 toi2.
two tables
啲 — the one with no Mandarin equivalent
啲 is the classifier for an unspecified quantity: some, and the plural. It is everywhere, and there is no single Mandarin word that covers it.
我買咗啲嘢。
Ngo5 maai5zo2 di1 je5.
I bought some things.
呢啲書好貴。
Ni1 di1 syu1 hou2 gwai3.
These books are expensive.
A classifier on its own means “the”
This is the construction worth learning early, and Mandarin has no way to do it. Drop the number and the demonstrative, leave the classifier, and the noun becomes definite — a specific one, already known to both of you.
本書好好睇。
Bun2 syu1 hou2 hou2tai2.
The book is very good.
架車喺出面。
Gaa3 ce1 hai2 ceot1min6.
The car’s outside.
Mandarin would need 那本书 or 这本书 and would still be pointing rather than simply referring. Cantonese does with one syllable what English does with the, and it is one of the clearest signs that the two languages are not the same grammar in different clothes.
Dropping the 一
With a number of one, the 一 is usually left out and the classifier stands alone — which reads as a rather than one, and is distinguished from the definite use above only by context.
我想飲杯咖啡。
Ngo5 soeng2 jam2 bui1 gaa3fe1.
I’d like a coffee.
我有三書。
我有三本書。
As in Mandarin, a bare number and noun leave the sentence unparsable rather than merely foreign-sounding.